Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Notice the quotes around the "8 seconds" rule. It's not a rule, but that's what it is known as. I mainly know it from the audio world, but it was a common theme/trope/meme in radio shows about using music without royalties.

Whether or not it's described in the text of copyright law, it is a common concept people are familiar.



Nitpickiest of nits: given your intended description, the quotes should be around “rule” not “8 second”. When around “rule”, that implies it’s not really a rule. When around “8 second” it implies that it’s not 8 seconds exactly or it’s what it’s colloquially called, but it would still be a rule.

Regardless, the fair use laws are very loose and tend to vary depending on the medium type and association with product.

Anyway , I get what you’re saying but given it’s part of a product page, it should at the very least, call out that they’re illustrative and not actually associated.


Do you really think that this company is implying that they made The Matrix or Dune? It is clearly just an example used to aid in the discussion of the surrounding text. There is no claim of "we used this software to make Dune". If they had, you can assume they would have put that out in some sort of call out in their marketing.

If you were confused by the image as them trying to take credit, then boy, I don't know.


I don’t know why you default to being hostile.

I’m just stating that they’re intermixing it and that can play into whether it is fair use. I’m not saying that I personally am confused. I’m just saying that intermixing it may give people the wrong assumption if they’re not familiar with these films. Remember, the matrix came out 25 years ago. There’s many people who will likely never see it but will be working in film/cinema etc and use this.

I’m not ascribing malice either, just that it’s good form in the industry to delineate clearly.

Maybe take it down a few notches or step away from the keyboard.


You are reading way more into these comments than is actually there. Just because someone challenges something you've written does not mean you are being attacked. There's no notches to take it down from.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: